Product | Overview | Pros | Cons |
---|---|---|---|
Tamarind Pod | -Large peanut-shaped pods with tamarind pulp on the inside.
-Sold in sweet and sweet-sour varieties. |
-Freshest, most balanced sweet and sour tamarind flavor; least processed. | -Requires effort to crack, deseed, and process into paste before use.
-Most products in the United States are the sweet variety, which is better suited for snacking and use in desserts rather than savory applications. |
Tamarind Pulp | -Inner flesh sold in wet or dehydrated brown blocks. | -Fresh, balanced sweet and sour flavor.
-Dehydrated blocks don’t need refrigeration. |
-Requires effort to deseed and process into paste before use. |
Bottled Tamarind Paste/Concentrate | -Processed pulp in a thick paste.
-Indian brands are more black, syrupy, and sour compared to others, which are brown and liquidy. |
-Ready-to-use tamarind product that doesn’t require additional work at home. | -Often has an artificial flavor from preservatives used to extend the paste’s shelf life. |
Tamarind Powder | -Dehydrated ground pulp mixed with cornstarch. | -Adds a concentrated sweet and sour flavor without contributing additional moisture.
-Can be stored in the pantry. |
-The most difficult tamarind product to source. |
Whole Tamarind Pods
The least processed form of tamarind you can buy, whole tamarind pods are large brown peanut-shaped fruits with pulp and seeds on the inside. The pods are typically sold either in large plastic bags or boxes. When purchasing tamarind pods, Gutierrez says to “press on the tamarind pod to check if the hard shell is crunchy and breaks easily. There shouldn’t be any fungus or mold that is growing.” Another trick I use that doesn’t require pressing on the tamarind is to find a bag with a higher distribution of longer pods, as the longer pods are easier to crack, which indicates quality.
How and when to use whole tamarind pods: The pulp inside the tamarind pods is what is used for cooking or eating. “In Guatemala, where I grew up, we would peel tamarind and eat them,” says Gutierrez. “The peel, of course, is like a peanut peel, [but] a little bit messier because it sticks to the inside of the tamarind. We would suck on the tamarind and make sure not to eat the big seeds. The pleasure of eating just tamarind, like that, for me, is huge.”
Most tamarind pods sold in the US are labeled as “sweet tamarind” because they are more sweet than sour; sour varieties are typically processed into tamarind pulp. Chongchitnant prefers using sweet tamarind pods for snacking rather than cooking, since savory dishes like pad thai benefit from the sour flavor of tamarind pulp. The pulp from the sweet tamarind pods can also be used to make homemade sweet treats like caramels or fruit leathers.
Storing whole tamarind pods: Whole, unpeeled tamarind pods can be stored in the fridge, where they should last for several weeks, according to Chongchitnant.
Tamarind Pulp
Tamarind pulp is the inner flesh of the tamarind pod, typically sold in large, compressed blocks that are dark brown and either wet or dehydrated. The wet variety, which is more widely available, is semi-processed with some fibers and seeds removed, though a few usually remain. The dehydrated version, often found in Indian and Middle Eastern stores, is a dark brown-black color and contains all fibers and seeds, making it harder in texture but more shelf-stable.
How and when to use tamarind pulp: Both the wet and dehydrated pulps need to be processed into homemade pastes before use in recipes, but the effort is worth it for the balanced tart and sweet flavor they provide.
To make homemade tamarind paste from pulp, break apart a small piece of the pulp and steep it in boiling water for at least 15 minutes. Once it’s cool enough to handle, squeeze and mash the pulp to separate it from the fibers and seeds. Strain the mixture through a sieve, using more water for a diluted paste that’s ideal for stews or curries, and less water for a thicker paste suited for marinades or stir-fries.
This same method can also be used to make a paste from the pulp inside whole tamarind pods, but, since these pods are normally sweet, they will in turn yield a homemade paste that is also sweet.
Storing tamarind pulp and homemade tamarind paste: A wet tamarind block can be stored at room temperature until opened, after which it should be refrigerated and will last several weeks. A dehydrated tamarind block, however, can remain at room temperature even after opening, and can last well over a year. The homemade paste made from the pulp can be stored in the fridge for several weeks.
“If I’m going to make [tamarind paste from pulp], I’m going to make a large batch that is going to last me for years,” says Martinez. “I freeze them in bags for a future day. If all I need is a couple tablespoons for a recipe, I can break off a piece like it’s an ice cube, and then throw it in a pot.”
Tamarind Paste or Tamarind Concentrate
Tamarind paste and concentrate sold in stores are ready-to-use products made from processed tamarind pulp or pods, free of seeds and fibers. However, the labels “tamarind concentrate” and “tamarind paste” are used interchangeably, which can cause confusion when reading recipes and shopping. However, you can know more about what kind of product you’re getting not from these labels, but rather from where the product was made. If the tamarind is from Thailand, Vietnam, or Latin America, it will be a brown liquid, while Indian tamarind concentrate is black and sticky; these two types cannot be used interchangeably. In general, Indian tamarind pastes like Tamicon are typically more intense, requiring only a teaspoon for a strong sour flavor compared to Thai, Vietnamese, or Latin American brands like Aroy-D and Cock, which require at least a tablespoon.
How and when to use tamarind paste or concentrate: When following recipes—especially when tamarind is the star ingredient in the dish—my preferred method is to make tamarind paste from scratch instead of using store-bought concentrate or pastes, as it yields the freshest and purest taste. In my experience, most store-bought pastes and concentrates contain preservatives like citric acid, which can impart an artificial flavor, similar to how bottled lemon juice will taste less sweet and more tart than fresh lemon juice.
“When I was developing a recipe for a tamarind salsa, I tested the bottled paste vs. the homemade paste,” says Martinez. “I realized that you might hate that salsa as a result of the processed taste of the bottled paste. It’s similar to if you’re making a tomato salsa—if you don’t have good tomatoes, you kind of ruin your salsa. However, in my book Mi Cocina, I have a tamarind shrimp recipe. I was a little less concerned about using bottled paste here, because when you’re using it, there are so many other flavors involved.”
The bottled pastes are my go-to when I need to get dinner on the table fast and I don’t have time to make homemade tamarind paste. Non-Indian bottled tamarind paste and homemade paste made from pulp or pods can often be used interchangeably.
I normally start with half the recommended amount of tamarind paste, and taste and adjust to achieve my desired balance of sweet and sour. “Different brands of tamarind paste vary greatly in acidity, so you always need to taste and adjust your dish whenever you cook with tamarind,” says Chongchitnant. Because of this, it’s best to use the exact brand recommended in the recipe, or a paste from the same region as the recommended brand. If no brand is specified, I use Indian brands for Indian recipes and non-Indian brands for all others.
“You can adjust the recipe and make it sweeter by adding more sugar, or adding a little bit of lime juice or lemon juice for acidity,” says Gutierrez.
Storing tamarind paste or concentrate: Bottled tamarind pastes and concentrates can be stored in the pantry until opened, then refrigerated, where they typically last at least 12 months.
Tamarind Powder
Tamarind powder—made from tamarind pulp that’s dehydrated and ground, then mixed with cornstarch to prevent clumping—is a tangy, brown powder that delivers a sour kick similar to the coating on sour candy. Out of all the tamarind products, it’s the most difficult one to source in stores, likely because it’s newer to the market, but it’s easily found online.
How and when to use tamarind powder: Tamarind powder is best used in a recipe where you want to add the flavor of tamarind without incorporating excess liquid. It works great in dry spice blends, as a dusting for chicken wings, or for rimming cocktail glasses.
“I like the powder because it delivers on the mouth-watering sour flavor that I love without having to change the texture of the dish or add liquid,” says Balingat. In Balingit’s book, Mayumu, she calls for tamarind powder in her sampalok tajin snickerdoodles to keep excess moisture out of the cookies, preserve their texture, and provide a second acidic component alongside cream of tartar for complex flavor results.
Storing tamarind powder: When stored in a cool, dark spot in your spice cabinet or pantry, tamarind powder should be used within six to eight months after opening, after which it will begin to lose its flavor.
Recipes That Use Tamarind
There are a number of dishes across various cuisines that highlight tamarind’s sweet and sour notes.
Tamarind in Indian Cuisine
Tamarind paste is used as a souring agent in Indian dishes like fish curries and hearty lentil stews like sambar, where it adds a pop of acidity. Growing up, my mom would make tamarind rice for school lunches by adding a thick tamarind paste with spices and tossing it with fluffy basmati rice for a sour and spicy dish. Tamarind paste is a non-negotiable in dishes like rasam, where it contributes a mouth-puckering tang. It’s also added to chutneys like tamarind date chutney and tomato chutney for a boost of brightness.
Tamarind in Thai Cuisine
Thai cooking leans on tamarind paste as a souring component in stir-fries and sauces. Pad thai is one of Chongchitnant’s favorite Thai dishes that uses tamarind, and other dishes that play on the sweet and sour characteristics of this ingredient include massaman curry, Thai fried eggs in tamarind sauce, and Thai red snapper and green papaya sour curry.
Thai Recipes Using Tamarind
Tamarind in Filipino Cuisine
In the Philippines, tamarind is used heavily in all kinds of applications like sampalok (tamarind) candies coated with sweet or spicy coatings. But Balingat notes that the most popular Filipino dish that features tamarind is sinigang. “It uses tamarind and tomatoes for a super sour stew,” she says. “There is something about every bite that doesn’t get tiring because of the sour taste in every bite.”
Tamarind in Mexican and Other Latin American Cuisines
Martinez notes that in Mexican cuisine, tamarind pulp is used in a lot of different drinks. “A very popular tamarind drink in Mexico is agua de tamarindo,” he says. “Fresh tamarind is added to a five-gallon batch of agua fresca to serve with meals. The drink is really balanced; there’s a good amount of acidity to it, and not too sweet. Folks also use jicama like a paleta and drizzle it in tamarind syrup and chamoy, then sprinkle tajin and give it to kids. It’s like a sweet-sour tamarind popsicle that doesn’t melt even if it is 100 degrees.” Gutierrez also suggests mixing tamarind into margaritas or micheladas “to add another dimension of sweetness.” The key to doing this successfully is starting with small amounts and adjusting to your liking.
Tamarind and Palm Sugar Popsicles With Chili Salt
More widely in Latin American cooking, tamarind can be used anywhere you need to add a little bit of acid and sweetness to a dish, and its acidity also helps break down the proteins in meat. “I like to use [tamarind] in tough cuts like briskets or the lesser cuts of beef and goat that are a little bit harder to cook down and to make tender and fall apart,” explains Gutierrez. She also encourages using it in desserts, sauces, and vinaigrettes. “Growing up, we had a mouth-watering dessert called mil hojas, with layers of puff pastry, egg custard, and tamarind sauce,” says Gutierrez.
The Takeaway
Tamarind is a versatile fruit available in various forms: pods, pulp, paste, and powder. Each has its own uses, but they all contribute a distinctively sweet and sour flavor to dishes. Tamarind pods are great for snacking, while homemade paste made from pulp offers the freshest and most balanced flavor. Store-bought tamarind paste is great when you’re short on time, and tamarind powder adds tang without contributing excess liquid to a recipe. This sweet and sour ingredient imparts a fruity tang to Indian, Thai, Filipino, Mexican, and Latin American cuisines, to name a few, making it a valuable addition to your kitchen pantry.